Could a gas giant give birth to a planet or is that preposterous?

Science & Mathematics by Anonymous 2018-06-09 22:04:32

Social Science

13 answers

Anonymous

A gas giant is a planet.
Anonymous

a GAS GIANT has very high gravity so if anything hit it everything would stay THERE. Jupiter has 2.4 times that of earth
Anonymous

Gas giants are a kind of planet. Planets don't give birth.
Anonymous

Pretty much impossible.
Anonymous

A major nutcase in the 1950s, Immanuel Velikovsky, claimed that, but totally absurd, ignores energy and a dozen other problems.
Anonymous

If there was a big enough collision, a quantity could be stripped off Just like the proto Planet Theia helped form our Moon Somewhere in the vast Cosmos it could have already happened A Supermassive Gas Giant with a Gas moon
Anonymous

Planets don’t give birth...
Anonymous

The moon is Earth's baby, so probably. Another large celestial body slammed into Earth then out came the moon. The Sun slapped it on the behind, then the moon started orbiting.
Anonymous

It is not preposterous, just not possible.
Anonymous

Not probable.
Anonymous

Gas Giants like Jupiter are made up of volatile gasses and do not have a rocky core as modern science defines them. So no, is quite impossible.
Anonymous

If it was hit by something big, yes. Otherwise, preposterous.
Anonymous

Preposterous.